N3-N2 (Intermediate) Travel History

Tokyo vs. Osaka: Which City Faces More Criticism?

May 19, 2024

As a fellow Canuck who’s had the pleasure of visiting both these vibrant Japanese cities, I’ve often heard debates about Tokyo and Osaka, and which one tends to rub people the wrong way more often. It’s an interesting discussion, eh?

Tokyo, as the sprawling metropolis and capital of Japan, often gets flak for its hustle and bustle. Some folks say it’s too busy, too crowded, and, well, too expensive. The fast-paced lifestyle can be overwhelming, and the cost of living there is certainly no joke. On top of that, some people find the residents a bit more reserved compared to other places.

On the other hand, Osaka prides itself on being more laid-back and friendly, at least by Japanese standards. But it’s not without its critics, either. Some travellers find it a bit rough around the edges, and it doesn’t have the same polish or reputation for cleanliness that Tokyo holds. The local dialect can be a bit of a curveball if you’re used to Tokyo's more standard Japanese, and for some, the casual vibe might come across as a bit too informal.

At the end of the day, both cities have their pros and cons, and which one faces more criticism often boils down to personal preference. It’s kind of like comparing Toronto to Vancouver—each has its own unique flavour, and what one person loves, another might not be so keen on.

So, which do you reckon faces more criticism, eh?

Disliked Prefecture (Source: タウンネット)

According to a chart put together by J-Town, a Japanese regional info website, the most disliked prefectures seem to be split clearly between Tokyo in Eastern Japan and Osaka in Western Japan. Tokyo and Osaka are Japan's two main cities and have had a long-running rivalry, but the reasons for the dislike appear to vary. Here’s a quick breakdown of why folks aren't too fond of Tokyo and Osaka.

Reasons for disliking Tokyo:
・There are just too many people, and a lot of them seem kind of cold.
・There's a ton of news about crimes and accidents, which makes it seem like the public safety isn’t great.
・Living costs are through the roof.

Reasons for disliking Osaka:
・Not a fan of the Kansai dialect.
・People tend to speak loudly and use rough language.
・The place has a reputation for having lots of yakuza and delinquents.

What do you think? No matter where you go, there are always folks who aren’t keen on the big cities, eh? If there's a country or region you’re not too fond of, let us know in the comments!

Japanese (日本語)


東京とうきょうvs.大阪おおさか きらわれてるのはどっち?


日本にほん地域ちいき情報じょうほうサイト、Jタウンがまとめたによると、西日本にしにほん東日本ひがしにほんきらいな都道府県とどうふけん東京とうきょう大阪おおさかにはっきりとかれていることがわかりました。東京とうきょう大阪おおさかといえば日本にほん二大にだい都市としで、ふるくからライバル関係かんけいにありますが、きらわれている理由りゆうことなるようです。東京とうきょうきらいな理由りゆう大阪おおさかきらいな理由りゆうについてまとめてみました。

東京とうきょうきらいな理由りゆう
ひとおおすぎる。つめたいひとおおい。
犯罪はんざい事故じこなど報道ほうどうおおく、治安ちあんわるいイメージ。
・とにかく物価ぶっかたかい。

大阪おおさかきらいな理由りゆう
関西弁かんさいべん苦手にがて
こえおおきくて言葉遣ことばづかいがあらい。
・ヤクザや不良ふりょうがたくさんいるイメージ。

どうでしたか?どこの地域ちいきでも、有名ゆうめい都市としきらいなひとおおいですよね。 あなたのきらいなくに地域ちいきがあればコメントらんでぜひおしえてください。

Sentence Quiz (文章問題)

Frankly, I'm not a big fan of the countryside.

僕は田舎が正直嫌い。

Osaka is a big city, eh, but the cost of living is pretty affordable.

大阪は都会なのに物価が安い。

The relationship between Tokyo and Osaka is a lot like the one between New York and Los Angeles.

東京と大阪の関係はNYとLAのようだ。

Tokyo isn’t really a spot to settle down, but it's definitely a place to have a great time.

東京は住む場所ではなく、遊ぶ場所だ。

Related Words (関連ワード)

Toggle Button

JapaneseHiraganaEnglish (CA)
地域ちいきRegion
情報じょうほうInformation
西日本にしにほんWestern Japan
東日本ひがしにほんEastern Japan
嫌いきらいDislike
都道府県とどうふけんPrefecture
東京とうきょうTokyo
大阪おおさかOsaka
都市としCity
ライバルらいばるRival
理由りゆうReason
冷たいつめたいCold
犯罪はんざいCrime
事故じこAccident
治安ちあんPublic safety
物価ぶっかCost of living
言葉遣いことばづかいSelection of words
ヤクザやくざYakuza
不良ふりょうDelinquent
有名ゆうめいFamosa

*This article has been translated by AI. For more accurate information, please click here to view the original. (The original text is in American English and Japanese.)

Created by Hiroto T. Murakami.

-N3-N2 (Intermediate), Travel, History